• News

  • TV & Film

  • PlayStation

  • Xbox

  • Nintendo

  • PC

  • Reviews

  • News

  • TV & Film

  • PlayStation

  • Xbox

  • Nintendo

  • PC

  • Reviews

  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • UNILAD
  • SPORTbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Snapchat
TikTok
YouTube
Threads
Submit Your Content
Harry Potter fans seriously divided over controversial change to Snape

Home> News> TV and Film

Published 11:31 3 Feb 2025 GMT

Harry Potter fans seriously divided over controversial change to Snape

This would have ruined the character

Sam Cawley

Sam Cawley

The film version of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 was going to have a very different ending for Snape, which the late Alan Rickman argued against.

The Harry Potter films were a fantastic adaptation of the books, and while almost every character had a chance to shine, none shined brighter than Alan Rickman’s Severus Snape.

Starting out as a side antagonist to Harry in the first book/film Snape was eventually revealed to be a hero in disguise during the final film

Advert

Snape met his end in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2, when Voldemort unleashed his pet snake Nagini on him, killing him with poison.

Apparently director David Yates had a different idea though, wanting Snape to be killed off with a spell by Voldemort instead.

Reddit user Windsofheaven_ shared an excerpt from Rickman’s diary talking about the change, which read: “David Y stubborn as ever about V[oldemort] killing me with a spell. (Impossible to comprehend, not least the resultant wrath of the readers.)

“Great working with Ralph, though. Direct and true and inventive and free. Back home and Rima (narrative brainbox) says, "He can't kill you with a spell - the only one that would do that is Avada Kedavra and it kills instantly - you wouldn't be able to finish the scene.'”

The whole point of the scene was for Snape to have a slow death that allowed him to provide Harry with his memories, something that wouldn't have been effective, or even possible, if Snape had just perished instantly.

“Well, that's stupid” replied one fan, and another said “I’m not surprised, Yates pretty much saw wands as fantasy guns.”

Fortunately that wasn’t how the scene played out, and we got an emotional send-off to arguably the best character in the series.

Featured Image Credit: Warner Bros

Topics: Harry Potter, TV And Film

Advert

Advert

Advert

Choose your content:

an hour ago
2 hours ago
3 hours ago
4 hours ago
  • 2K Games
    an hour ago

    Amazon Drops 10 Free Games Including AAA Bangers, Don't Miss Out

    Yours to keep once claimed

    News
  • Gameloft
    2 hours ago

    Animal Crossing and Stardew Valley Competitor Drops Free New-Gen Upgrade

    A cosy weekend awaits

    News
  • 2K
    3 hours ago

    Legendary Strategy Classic Free On PC, Only For a Limited Time

    Play this fantastic game ASAP!

    News
  • Whitethorn Games
    4 hours ago

    Free 9/10 PS5 Game For PC Gamers, Perfect For a Chill Weekend

    Add this free game to your collection

    News
  • Harry Potter TV Reboot Release Window Revealed, 5 Things We Need to See
  • Harry Potter fans divided over Ron’s fate after Deathly Hallows
  • Harry Potter fans divided over dark wizard who 'created' dementors
  • Harry Potter fans divided over Voldemort's new look for HBO series