• News

  • TV & Film

  • PlayStation

  • Xbox

  • Nintendo

  • PC

  • Reviews

  • News

  • TV & Film

  • PlayStation

  • Xbox

  • Nintendo

  • PC

  • Reviews

  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • UNILAD
  • SPORTbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Snapchat
TikTok
YouTube
Threads
Submit Your Content
Star Wars fans torn over live-action Luke Skywalker replacement: ‘he’s too old’

Home> News> TV and Film

Published 07:00 18 May 2025 GMT+1

Star Wars fans torn over live-action Luke Skywalker replacement: ‘he’s too old’

Is he too old?

Richard Lee Breslin

Richard Lee Breslin

Star Wars fans are torn over who could be the next live-action Luke Skywalker, but some say that his potential replacement is “too old”.

If there ever comes a time when Disney and Lucasfilm decide to recast the role of Luke Skywalker in a Star Wars live-action movie or TV series, it will undoubtedly be controversial, regardless.

Luke Skywalker actor Mark Hamill says that he’s done with the legendary character, which only leaves a handful of options. Recast the role with another actor, use AI with Mark Hamill’s likeness and voice (again) or just let Luke Skywalker retire happily as a Jedi ghost.

Advert

Check out the Star Wars: A New Hope trailer below!

So, if Disney and Lucasfilm were to recast the live-action role of Luke Skywalker, who would they hire for the role?

A popular choice with fans over the years has been Sebastian Stan, perhaps best known for playing Bucky Barnes aka Winter Soldier in the MCU.

Advert

However, at the not-old whatsoever age of 42, some feel the opportunity for Sebastian Stan to play Luke Skywalker has passed, despite Mark Hamill backing the actor.

“What would you think of a movie starring Sebastian Stan and Rachel Brosnahan as Luke and Leia, respectively?” asked Redditor Castanha_de_Marte. Rachel Brosnahan, age 34 at the time of writing, is set to play Lois Lane in Superman, directed and written by James Gunn.



Advert

“I feel like Stan’s getting a little old to be ‘young Luke’,” replied Zark_Muckerberger with FearsomeTaco adding, “I think he’s the perfect age to be ‘middle-aged Luke’, though.”

The baby-faced Mark Hamill was 24 years old when he played Luke Skywalker in 1977’s Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope.

“I've been wanting Sebastian Stan to play Luke since Captain America: Winter Soldier (2014) came out,” said TheFluffyEngineer. “Yep, it should have been done years ago,” responded themanfromvulcan.

I don't doubt that if cast in the role of Luke Skywalker, Sebastian Stan would knock it out of the park but I feel that such an iconic live-action role should be left to the one and only, Mark Hamill.

Advert

You can watch the entire Star Wars saga now on Disney Plus.

Featured Image Credit: Disney Plus

Topics: Disney, TV And Film, Star Wars

Advert

Advert

Advert

  • Star Wars' Mark Hamill backs his Luke Skywalker replacement
  • Star Wars fans divided over live-action Luke and Leia recasting, and we get it
  • Star Wars fans divided over controversial Anakin Skywalker recasting
  • Star Wars brings back Luke Skywalker for new sequel to OG Trilogy

Choose your content:

a minute ago
6 hours ago
  • a minute ago

    Star Wars' controversial recast nailed it, fans agree

    Did you like the recast?

    News
  • 6 hours ago

    GTA 6 fans in love with new game blowing up on Steam right now

    Bizarro Grand Theft Auto

    News
  • 6 hours ago

    Steam freebie is one Stardew Valley fans will adore

    Embark on a new farming adventure

    News
  • 6 hours ago

    Fallout 5 be damned, we’re officially getting loads more Fallout and fans are buzzing

    The future is looking bright... and nuclear

    News